When a CFO Says “Our Health Insurance Is Too Expensive,” I Don’t Start With Quotes

Promotional graphic titled "When a CFO tells me, 'Our health insurance is too expensive,' I don't immediately start looking for quotes." Al Schiebel, wearing a red Oakbridge Insurance polo, sits at his office desk with his hand on his chin and a thoughtful, skeptical expression. An LSU banner, a framed stadium photo and a gold football helmet are visible in the office behind him. The headline is in bold navy text on the right, with the CFO's quote set in italics on a light green highlight under the Oakbridge Insurance logo. The navy footer shows Al Schiebel, Employee Benefits Advisor and Medicare Expert, with aschiebel@oakbridgeinsurance.com and 404-256-2171.

It’s one of the most common things I hear from financial leaders: “Our health insurance is too expensive.” The natural reaction is to start collecting quotes right away. I don’t. Before I look at a single quote, I ask one question: What’s making it too expensive?

That question matters because “too expensive” can mean a lot of different things. It might be rising premiums. It might be deductibles so high that employees avoid care. It could be prescription costs climbing year after year, or a 25% renewal increase that landed with no warning. Each of these is a different problem, and different problems need different solutions.

Questions to Answer Before You Shop

Before we request quotes from anyone, I want a clear picture of what’s actually going on. That starts with a few honest questions:

  • What’s driving the costs? Premiums, claims, prescriptions, and plan design all point to different fixes.
  • Who’s feeling the financial pressure? Is the strain mostly on the employer, on employees, or on both?
  • What have you already tried? And just as important, did it work?

Sometimes changing carriers is the right call. Other times, the better answer is smarter plan design, prescription management, or helping employees understand how to use their benefits well. You can’t tell which one fits until you know what you’re solving for.


Three Quotes Aren’t a Strategy

For CFOs, HR leaders, and business owners, a stack of quotes can feel like progress. But if a new carrier doesn’t address the thing actually driving your costs, you’re likely to end up having the same conversation again next year. Three quotes aren’t a strategy. Understanding the problem comes first, and the right solution follows from there.

“If we don’t understand the problem, how do we know another quote will solve it?”

If your renewal is approaching, the best time to talk is before the numbers arrive.


Let’s Look Beyond the Spreadsheet

If you’re ready to stop guessing and start managing your benefits proactively, we can help you uncover the real story behind your numbers. We work with employers of 20 or more employees across Georgia, South Carolina, and Tennessee.

Connect with Al Schiebel today:

ShopBenefits is an Oakbridge Insurance Agency partner.